GTA vs. Real Life: Taxi Driving

GTA and ‘real life’ pictures of the same intersection in San Francisco
Above: The intersection on Hyde and Lombard Streets, just above the start of the curvy portion of Lombard, as seen in real life and Grand Theft Auto.

Note the GTA version shows the Transamerica building clearly to the east although Coit Tower actually is the most visible structure and the Transamerica building isn’t visible at all from the top of Hyde/Lombard. Draw distance is also significantly higher in real life than on the PS2, at least on clear days.

I am a big fan of the taxi driving mission on the Grand Theft Auto series. After driving taxi in real life for a few months here is a quick comparison of the two experiences…
Continue reading

Posted in media, taxi | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

More cabs on City streets in 2008, but we still need peak medallions.

A Luxor Cab stopped at an intersection

The Examiner reports the City will finally see more cabs on the streets in 2008.

As both a cab driver and a City resident, this is bittersweet.

As a resident, this seems like City progress. Finally, I’ll have a better chance getting a taxi on Friday night!

As a cab driver, this is frustrating. My average income will decrease as more cabs will be on the street. I won’t get as many fares.

As a critic of City policy and management, this appears to be poor resource allocation. We don’t need more cabs on the street most of the time. Only 3 out of 14 shifts per week (2 per day x 7 days) need more cabs: Thu, Fri and Sat nights.

Instead of issuing medallions valid at all times, the City should issue more medallions for Thu, Fri and Sat nights, a concept known as “peak medallions.” I’ve written about this before.

Issuing peak medallions decreases the environmental and labor waste from extra cabs driving on the street during the remaining 11 shifts that don’t need any more cabs (good for City residents). This also prevents further salary erosion for current and future taxi drivers (good for drivers).

Taxi Commission, you work for the residents of the City. Do your job and serve them best with peak medallions.

Link

Posted in econ, taxi, transit | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Correlation does not indicate causation.

Night shift

The AP syndicated this article today claiming that “working the graveyard shift will soon be listed as a ‘probable’ cause of cancer.”

This is bullshit.

This report, published by the World Health Organization, surely does NOT claim that working the nightshift causes cancer. It most likely describes a correlation and includes theories about what causes this correlation. (I could not find a copy of the report on the WHO or IARC websites.)

The article paints such a sharp picture of “night shift = cancer” that it reeks of irresponsible and sensational reporting. Not something to expect of the AP, eh?

Where is the discussion about other factors that are correlated with night shifts? This is a guess, but I’d bet a lot of money that night shift work is correlated with low income and low education. This article points to the correlation between low income and breast cancer.

In many cases, the cause of cancer is a mystery. There’s a whole lot we don’t know about cancer. Misleading articles like these promote fear and misunderstanding. They should be accompanied with a clearer explanation of the difference between correlation and causality.

Link

Posted in media | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Post-Thanksgiving Cab Driving

BLACK FRIDAY!!!

Starting with Thanksgiving I drove 4 days in a row, a first for me. I wore out quickly. The driving doesn’t phase me nearly as much as waking up so early (5am). I didn’t get enough sleep any night.

After Thanksgiving, Friday through Sunday all blurred together into one gigantic taxi driving shift separated by brief periods of sleep.

Over the few days:

  • Downtown, especially Union Square, was packed with pedestrians and idiot drivers waiting in queues for the parking garages. I was dangerously close to screaming “CONGESTION CHARGE!” but I kept it to myself.
  • I drove a nice lady from the Castro to Lower Haight. It turned out that she works for Green Cab. We talked for a few minutes even after we got to her destination. She’s been driving for 4 years and still loves it.
  • I picked up from the airport for the first time in a while. Sunday everyone was returning to the City from visiting their family across the US (and beyond). The airport moved quickly.
  • I listened to so much San Francisco FM radio that my head wanted to explode. I flip around between 104.5, 105.3, 106.9, 107.7, 92.7, 99.7, 88.5, 91.1, 91.7 and 102.1. Even the classical 102.1 plays excessive amounts of ads. 104.5 is the best on Sunday mornings with its ‘acoustic sunrise’ which is commercial free from 9am to 10am. I think it’s about time I purchased an iPod.
  • I took a couple of gay guys from the Western Addition to do some after-Thanksgiving shopping at Best Buy. They were surprised and impressed that I was listening to 92.7, a dance music only station with a gay male target audience.
  • I took an older lady from a hospital to her home near the southern border of the San Francisco City and County. I had no idea how to get there, but she was extremely kind in giving me directions. She gave me a great tip too because she said I drove very safely. Thanks, lady.
  • This was my worst weekend ever (in terms of earnings). My average hourly wage among all four shifts was about $12/hr, considerably less than my all-time mean hourly wage of $19/hr. But, it was still an enjoyable experience. These shifts actually dropped my all-time mean hourly wage to below $19/hr for the first time.
  • I heard a cool econ idea on the EconTalk podcast: buyers can benefit (or ‘profit’) from a transaction just as a seller benefits (usually in the form of profits). A buyer has an upper limit he or she is willing to pay for a product or service. If the buyer can find that product or service at a price less than that upper limit, they have benefitted from that transaction. Through my shifts this past weekend I tried to imagine what different upper limits people would have had in different situations:
    • People on Mission street early in the morning are often very eager to hail a cab. Many of them are late for work, BART doesn’t run before a certain hour and/or it doesn’t directly service their end destination, and, of course, MUNI is a disaster. Some may have been willing to pay 2 or 3 times the fare to prevent being fired.
    • In contrast, I will pick up ‘MUNI exiles’ who don’t want to wait any longer for the bus. They often seem to have just barely been ‘tipped’ over the line to hail a cab. Their upper limit is quite close to the actual fare.
    • Business folks with expense accounts heading to/from the airport are an interesting case. Since it’s not their money they don’t really care about pricing. Their primary currency is time. A cab is actually ‘cheapest’ for them, in that it is the fastest and most hassle-free way to arrive at their destination.
Posted in taxi, work | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Light Rail SMACKDOWN: Dublin’s LUAS vs. SF MUNI’s T-Third

Light Rail SMACKDOWN

Two world-class cities. Two new light rail lines.

Who will take all in the LIGHT RAIL SMACKDOWN?

Meet the contenders:

Continue reading

Posted in transit | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 8 Comments

Turkey Day Cab Driving

A turkey and a taxi

I worked on Thanksgiving. Things were slow until the afternoon when everyone (and their food) needed rides to join friends or family for Thanksgiving dinner.

It was fascinating to experience meeting so many people that consider SF ‘home’ such that they’ll spend Thanksgiving here.

  • I took a male nurse to work at the Kaiser. He brought an entire cooked turkey for his coworkers who had to work Thanksgiving evening. What a nice guy.
  • 2 ladies brought side dishes and a bunch of pie from the Mission to the Lower Haight.
  • I took a gay guy to the outer Mission for Thanksgiving dinner with some friends. He had just stopped to pick up the most important Thanksgiving ingredient for the group — vodka.
  • 3 gay guys brought a turkey across town from the Tendernob to the Castro.
  • Yuppies from Russian Hill took wine and pie up to Twin Peaks.
  • A gal that just broke up with her bf took some side dishes and wine to friends in the Sunset from the Haight.
  • And finally, two older ladies were skipping town to “get as far away from family as possible.” They were going to a beach resort in Hawaii.
Posted in taxi, work | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

San Francisco Supe proposes taxi gate fee increase. Drivers need gradual implementation.

Alioto-Pier with an arrow pointing up that reads Taxi Gates

The Examiner reports Supervisor Michela Alioto-Pier recently proposed a significant increase in taxi gate fees charged to cab drivers.

(Quick background: A ‘gate fee’ is the rental fee charged to a taxi driver for a shift. Taxi drivers pay the gate fee, plus gas and dispatcher/cashier tips. The current average gate fee for large companies — Yellow, Luxor and DeSoto — is $91.50. The proposed ordinance increases that average gate fee to $110.)

Obviously, most cab drivers, like all rational human beings, wouldn’t enjoy a 10% ($2/hr) pay cut. Are these gate increases necessary? Is this legislation desirable? Let’s discuss this a bit.

Does SF need a taxi gate fee increase?

Continue reading

Posted in econ, taxi, transit | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | 7 Comments

SF Central Subway is slowest slow motion train wreck in history.

Nightmare on Fourth Street

Do you like watching bloody transit carnage unfold? You’re in luck, here’s a doozy.

Check out these fantastic series of posts on the proposed Central Subway in San Francisco.

(Primer for the uninitiated: a proposal is on deck to extend the T-Third MUNI Metro line from the Cal Train station at 4th and King underground via 4th and Stockton Streets to Chinatown, ending somewhere around Clay Street. This is a map of the route.)

This is my favorite post of the series. Eric takes exceptional detail in explaining why the Central Subway wouldn’t work as proposed, especially under MUNI’s watch.

I agree wholeheartedly: the Central Subway is an unmitigated disaster in process. MUNI’s antiquated metro system is a relic of the ancient past, recently brought to its knees when the T-Third line began service despite nearly a billion dollars of capital investment into the system during that project. The last thing the City needs is to spend a billion dollars more on this piece of crap excuse for a light rail system.

Let’s stop writing these ridiculous capital checks to a city agency that can’t handle its current responsibilities. Sure, let’s give a loaded gun to a trigger happy convicted murderer in a crowded stadium! They’re gonna strike again, folks.

How about spending this gigantic chunk of change on immediately implementing smart transit options for the City? (Read: Geary + Van Ness BRT to start with.) Is this too much to ask? What do we pay (rather well) all these city planners for anyway? Why can transit novices like me realize the stupidity of these projects while our Supervisors think a Central Subway is the best thing we can do for the City? Hogwash.

Posted in politics, transit | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

Dear MUNI, wouldn’t it be nice…

Speed Movie Poster

Wouldn’t it be nice if San Francisco MUNI bus drivers had this sort of fire under their butts?

Link

PS. This should serve as yet another reminder of how little motivation and accountability MUNI drivers have. Let’s hope the passage of Proposition A moves accountability and performance forward.

Posted in transit | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

How much is a San Francisco taxi medallion worth?

San Francisco taxi medallion with dollar signs instead of a number

The Goldman School of Public Policy at UC Berkeley prepared an analysis of the City’s taxi medallion scheme in 2006.

Read it if you have a spare hour or so and if you enjoy these sorts of things. Here’s a summary if you want to keep your hour: the authors recommend switching to a transferable medallion scheme similar to New York City, allowing for sale and resale of driving medallions. Currently, San Francisco issues approximately 1,500 medallions to full-time drivers that have waited for 10+ years on a waiting list. (Basic primer: a cab must have a medallion to legally operate as a taxi in the City.) Drivers with medallions then lease back these medallions to cab companies who, in turn, lease the medallion and a car to shift drivers (like me).

Medallion holders must be able to safely drive 800 hours per year. As soon as he or she can no longer drive, the driver must forfeit the medallion back to the City at which time it is offered to the next driver on the list.

One effect of transferability (NYC) vs. permitting non-transferable medallions (SF) is a significant one-time revenue bump for the City plus ongoing City revenue via medallion transfer sale taxes. The report argues this would also yield a higher quality of life for drivers who purchase these transferable medallions, as selling a medallion upon retirement offers a significant windfall for a driver.

Whether or not San Francisco needs transferable medallions is a valid but complicated debate to be taken up elsewhere. (UPDATE 4/24/08: “elsewhere” is now apparently in the comments below.) I pose this question instead: if we had transferable medallions, how much would they be worth? Or, looking at it another way, how much are the collective medallion assets worth to the City taxpayers?
Continue reading

Posted in econ, taxi, transit | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 17 Comments